An AlterNet article wonderfully summarizes the strategies Big Pharma uses to scare the public.
That’s when the drug industry began debuting the concept of “treatment resistant depression.” It wasn’t that their drugs didn’t work (or you didn’t have depression in the first place), you had “treatment resistant depression.” Your first expensive and dangerous drug needed to be coupled with more expensive and dangerous drugs because monotherapy, one drug alone, wasn’t doing the trick!Essentially, Big Pharma casts almost everything as a potential problem. Every normal ailment a person experiences is listed as possibly leading to a more serious problem - for which a drug undoubtedly exists. So depression has evolved from an emotional problem legitimately affecting a small portion of the population to a one-size-fits-all explanation for laziness, mood swings, and, of course, back problems. Go to the doctor for back stiffness and you leave with some Cymbalta; makes sense, right.
Once upon a time, when depression was neither seasonal, atypical, bipolar or treatment resistant, it was considered to be a self-limiting disease. In fact, just about the only good thing you could say about depression was it wouldn’t last forever. But now, the drug industry is giving depression the don’t-wait scare treatment like coronary events (statins), asthma attacks (”controller” drugs) and thinning bones (Sally Field). If you don’t hurry and take medication, your depression will get worse!
Depression may masquerade as headaches, insomnia, fatigue, backache, dizziness, lightheadedness or appetite problems mongers the article. “You might feel queasy or nauseous. You might have diarrhea or become chronically constipated.” And here, you thought it was something you ate!
But the hypochondria doesn't stop there, it permeates essentially every aspect of mainstream health and nutritional rhetoric. Ever heard of "toxins", a farcical medical chimera concocted by the "alternative" medical community, e.g. Gaiaist quacks. Apparently, toxins fill your entire body, as in the religious notion of sin applied to health. Going further with the analogy, it would appear society believes everyone is born physically impure, with each of us on the verge of catastrophic disaster unless we do every single thing "they" tell us to do. Good idea to go on one of those "cleanse" diets popular amongst celebrities; it will release those darn "toxins" from your body.
I would be remiss to ignore the gender issue here. We already know the liberal-based underpinnings of the vegetarian diet, with meat-eating in part viewed as a reflection of the patriarchy. Additionally, one notes the sensationalism of standard medical advice. The media and medical establishment bombard us with these problems, with the clear implication that disease is inevitable. Sure, we should know about the current health epidemic, but I don't need a reminder about statins and erectile dysfunction every time I turn on the TV, open up a magazine, or watch the news. Of course, this affects women more because they tend towards histrionics easier than men do. With modern feminism imbuing women with undue confidence, they feel compelled to aver this hysteria both individually and collectively. That means husbands must suffer nagging about going to the doctor and not eating meat (oh the irony!). It means you can't get a McDonald's hamburger in San Francisco and kids will grow up without Happy Meals.
Going further, women, the credulous beings they are, have a faith in expert advice without any ability to confirm their advice independently. Roissy once described arguing with a woman as follows:
I hurled facts and figures at her, the holy water to the emotionally vampiric female soul. She reacted as a startled vampiress would; shrieks and bared fangs, her pallor drained from her face in shock at my bombshell impudence. “Why is he not kowtowing to me?”, I could practically hear her hamster morse coding to the nether reaches of her brain.It is rare to find a woman who has the ability to rationally consider statistics and facts. With the feel-good Gaism (another female phenomenon), exaggerated rhetoric, and expert authority that supports much of mainstream health advice, the task becomes that much more formidable for them. So we must listen to women who mindlessly regurgitate whatever misleading or downright false findings Big Pharma, liberal academia, and big government advertise this week.
And because I care, here's three studies I found recently:
Evidence of Human Adaptation to Increased Carnivory
Fiber Does not Prevent Cancer (H/T: Keoni Galt)
We Evolved to Eat Meat - Direct Evidence of Prehistoric Meal
23 comments:
'It is rare to find a woman who has the ability to rationally consider statistics and facts.'
C’mon! I like this blog for its intelligence but this....
I am in a field where you need to think quickly and combine primary inputs - numbers + statistical data. There seem to be an equal or almost equal number of women, some of them exceedingly smart and can keep up with men.
I know on average women score lower on IQ than men but blanket statements like this make you sound a bit kooky.
Roissy most likely tends to meet more of the short term oriented fucked up sluts – the overlap between fucked up sluts and feminists and normal women (like most normal men) is not that great yet.
Women seem very keen to reject 'white male' evidence for (or against) medical treatments in favour of intuitive, New Age bulllshit, but apart from Oprah and Deepak Chopra, everyone profiting from pandering to their emotional rather than rational needs is also a white man.
I've known about 5-6 serious hypochondriacs in my life and they've all been women.
One thing that was not discussed in this article was the fact that the biggest source of illness and depression is bad humours; bad humours enter the body through the skin pores or the air we breathe. Being bled regularly by your physicker can reduce the negative effect these bad humours have on a person, and keep them healthy and happy! another source of moodiness, irritability and bile is too much spleen. This symptom can also be relieved by being bled. Being bled also prevents the blood from stagnating in one's extremities; stagnation can lead to apoplexy.
A physicker can prescribe a scarificator which (if properly used) can prevent a myriad of illnesses and tempers.
As a woman, I agree that women can lean hypochondriac. I sometimes fall into it. Also, I know it is irrational, so sometimes I over compensate by ignoring stuff that I should pay attention to. It is kinda vexing to tell the truth.
Maybe women lean this way because they have to look out for health problems in their kids so the kids will survive. Moms who weren't alert or protective enough had fewer kids survive or some such.
Regarding the latter portion of your post, Roosh V nailed it:
"A woman thinks after reading a couple articles on Huffington Post she’s qualified to jam public policy down your throat, or that she can competently discuss statecraft. She’ll go to Thailand or Argentina for a week, glance at the abject poverty, hear about a new microlending organization, and then all of a sudden think she’s an expert on geopolitical concerns...She’ll read health articles in the New York Times and start making comments as if she’s a trained nutritionist. She’ll go on about the importance of feminism even though you may actually know more about the history of the movement than she does. The epitome of this overreach is your 35-year-old lonely spinster giving relationship advice when we all know the only relationships she’s qualified to discuss are those with felines." http://www.rooshv.com/never-listen-to-a-woman
Well, I often think there is more loot in finding problems than in finding solutions.
It probably our own fault, but it seems like people don't trust their own judgements anymore.
It may also be due to growing up in big cities. You can't just tell your kid in summer to "go outside!" and have them come back 10 hours later. I think kids benefit immensely from getting out of the house and getting in a bit of mischief. Mommy won't always be there.
Nice to see someone bash both Big Pharma and New Age quacks.
Yeah, "toxins"...LOL. The best way to get rid of the mostly imaginary toxins the New Agers think are clogging up your body is to eat a clean paleo diet and do hard, sweaty exercise every day. Short of ingesting poisonous mushrooms picked by some stoned hippie or eating mercury-tainted swordfish or huffing vinyl chloride monomer all day in some shitty factory job, you don't really have to worry very much about toxins.
I know on average women score lower on IQ than men but blanket statements like this make you sound a bit kooky
Actually, men and women (of the same race) have roughly the same average IQ. But more men are found at both ends of the spectrum: more submoron men and more supergenius men. Women cluster more around the middle of the bell curve.
By the way, it's quite possible to have a high IQ but be totally irrational about any number of subjects. Case in point: Bobby Fischer.
"A physicker can prescribe a scarificator which (if properly used) can prevent a myriad of illnesses and tempers."
Especially when combined with a generous draught of ladanum (170 proof) followed by a taking of the waters.
prawnster
"Maybe women lean this way because they have to look out for health problems in their kids so the kids will survive. Moms who weren't alert or protective enough had fewer kids survive or some such."
Yeah, because at one time there were all these rational nonhypochondriac women who didn't give a shit about themselves or their kids and they all died out in the long long ago because they neglected to take their chillens to the local witch doctor or physicker. Makes sense to me.
Question is, how did they ever come to exist in the first place? I guess evolution has to be stupid before it can be smart, or some such.
prawnster
I know plenty of men, even M.D's that prescribe to the theory of "toxins". Just because we don't have a name for them all yet doesn't mean that they aren't very real. An example of a disease brought about by toxins is Autism. Please do not tell me that conditions like autism are caused by genetics. It is most likely caused by toxins (i.e. environmental factors, viruses, heavy metals, lowered levels of glutathione, candida, etc...), and not only is autism very real, it is becoming more and more prevalent.
Yes, I agree that the pharmaceutical companies will market any and every drug the FDA allows them to for a whole litany of everyday ailments. They make some drugs that will kill you (statins) and some that will help to heal you (metformin).
I do not think that women are stupid to believe in toxins, nor do I believe that only women believe in them.
Socialism and capitalism share one critical characteristic- they are both consumerist. They both promise a better life, materially, for the common man.
US medical care is the Frankenstein's monster of socialist and capitalist consumerism. The individual chooses, and someone else pays. As Ronnie Cox shouted in "Robocop", "Who cares if the damn thing works?" If the treatment doesn't work, the consumer at least gets some placebe effect, and will go back for something else.
To anon@11:13am...
Your comment sounds like it came out of a medieval medical text and has no relationship to actual human physiology.
To Edwood@1:02 pm:
You may be right. Human female hormones(natural and synthetic)have been found to be responsible for the feminization of some fish and frogs and to estrogen-sensitive
breast cancers in women. They have
been linked(not yet documentated)
to to brain changes in humans and
animals and to increases of breast
tissue in many men. These substances are being found in drinking water supplies all over the developed world.
A good article can be found at www.
scientiareview,org./pdfs/169pdf.
It is my theory that these hormones
may be linked to the increase in
homosexuality and to the ever increasing number of autistic children who are primarily boys--
both through changes in the brain.
Geezerette: 46 years of experience
in acute health care setting and in nursing education.
One thing that was not discussed in this article was the fact that the biggest source of illness and depression is bad humours; bad humours enter the body through the skin pores or the air we breathe. Being bled regularly by your physicker can reduce the negative effect these bad humours have on a person, and keep them healthy and happy!
Another source of moodiness, irritability and bile is too much spleen. This symptom can also be relieved by being bled. Being bled also prevents the blood from stagnating in one's extremities; stagnation can lead to apoplexy.
A physicker can prescribe a scarificator which (if properly used) can prevent a myriad of illnesses and tempers.
Ha ha -- perfect. I was thinking along the same lines, but I couldn't remember the term "humors". I was thinking of "spirits" and such.
ONE....
You are correct about female hypochondria. I am in a group of
four women who have been friends for 20+ years-all senior citizens.
One has severe heart problems and
has two doctors(internal medicine,
cardiology) and goes to the doctor
only when necessary as do I. Two
have three and four doctors who
they see every three months-needed
or not and probably only because
Medicare and their supplemental insurance totally cover the bills.
It seems to be a status symbol that
they can talk frequently about their "doctors' appointments." One
changes one of her four doctors at least once a year because she does not like what the doctor tells her. And she is the most stupid of the bunch. All three believe many things they hear and not one ever
reads anything of value.
Since I've retired, I've spent a lot of time reading scientific medical articles/studies. One good
site is pubmed.
I've read enough that I quit taking
statins. One excellent site is www.cholesterol-and-health.com--well worth reading. Some of the paleo diet sites have excellent sites and references-animalpharm
being one. Also proteinpower has
some good reviews, references and some excellent sites listed in his
blogroll.
P.S. I guess one can tell that I am not familiar with html????!!
geezerette
Your comment sounds like it came out of a medieval medical text and has no relationship to actual human physiology.
Whoosh!
Magazines like Time or Newsweek that are aimed at baby boomer women are about 90% pharmacutical advertisements. Medicine for everything from accute depression to bladder infections are pedaled like candy. Same for the nightly network news.
second study about fiber should not have been posted. don't make good observations and then ruin them with poor links. thanks for your work
geezerette
pubmed is good, but not if you can just read the abstracts, which is equivalent to believing everything you read. o.O
"Magazines like Time or Newsweek that are aimed at baby boomer women are about 90% pharmacutical advertisements. Medicine for everything from accute depression to bladder infections are pedaled like candy. Same for the nightly network news."
Same goes for any TV channel with the word "Lifetime" in it.
prawnster
"geezerette" is absolutely the bestest Internet nickname I have ever read. I am still giggling, just thinking about it. I am a geezer m'self, into my seventh decade on this here ball of pain.
My Mom was apparently one of the rare ones. She was amazingly sharp, and managed the household finances much better than Dad could have done. In fact, she got up off of her deathbed to settle the property taxes for the house which Dad the salesman had ignored.
She really was just like that virtuous woman in Proverbs. She made her own clothes, instructed her children, cooked delicious meals, etc.
She was also quite the babe, judging from her high-school yearbook pic of 1940 or so.
I think this is why I have a hard time with most wimmin. Compared to my Mom, they are really quite disappointing.
Post a Comment